Brotherhood and the Cost of the Mask You Forgot You Were Wearing

Brotherhood and the Cost of the Mask You Forgot You Were Wearing

MASONIC LIFE

The Slightly Truer Thing

Brotherhood and the Cost of the Mask You Forgot You Were Wearing

The Room That Knows Your Name

There is a particular kind of loneliness that does not announce itself. It does not show up in an empty house or a silent phone. It shows up in a room full of men who know your name, sometimes have known it for decades, and you find yourself standing in the middle of that room feeling like a person behind glass.

It’s not because anyone is being unkind; it’s not because the Brothers are anything other than what they appear to be. The loneliness shows up because the person you present in the room is a very well-constructed version of you, and the actual you was not invited.

The mechanism is ordinary. You calibrate what you say before you say it. You read the room, run the internal check, trim the real answer, and produce the acceptable one. You do this automatically, often without noticing. Then you do it again. Over a long enough timeline, across enough lodge nights and dinners and conversations, you end up with relationships that are cordial, and often genuinely warm, but structurally unable to carry the weight of who you really are.

The research on loneliness is clear on this point: the subjective sense of isolation is largely independent of objective social contact. A person can be surrounded by people and still carry the signature of being alone. What drives it is not the absence of company, but the persistent sense that one’s real experience is not known to the people present.

The isolation, in this form, is self-generated. That is uncomfortable to sit with. It also means the door is not locked from the outside.

Photo: Brothers from the Grand Lodge of New York volunterring during the “Camp Turk Clean Up Weekend.” (2026)

What the Mask Was For

A previous piece in this series, Reading the Instrumentation, looked at what constant self-management costs you on the inside. This piece follows that thread outward: what does decades of calibration do to your relationships, and what would it take to begin, in small ways, to live without it?

The mask was protective. It was forged early, in environments where the unedited version of you produced consequences you could not absorb, and it stayed in service because it kept working. The problem is not that you developed the capacity. The problem is that it kept running long after the threats it was built for had passed, quietly enough that you stopped noticing it was on.

What you end up with is a man who is not only hidden from the people around him. He is meaningfully out of contact with himself. Years of producing the acceptable version instead of the actual one do not just conceal the real self from others. They conceal it from him. He stops being able to answer simple questions about what he wants, what he feels, what is actually true for him in a given moment, because the machinery that would have produced those answers has been disused long enough that it does not turn over reliably anymore.

That is the deeper isolation. It is not only that no one in the room knows him. He does not entirely know himself.

The Stone You Actually Brought

In A Mason’s Work, the Rough Ashlar is the unfinished stone: the self as it arrived, irregular, unpolished, and shaped by forces that worked on it before the tools were ever applied. The work of the lodge is not to reject that stone but to bring it gradually closer to its true form through patient, deliberate labor.

What most of us carry into our relationships is not the Rough Ashlar. It is a perfect stone veneer shaped less by genuine refinement than by accumulated judgment about what other people seemed to want to see. The Rough Ashlar, for all its irregularity, is at least honest about what it is. The performed stone is pretending to be further along than it is, and the pretense itself becomes one of the things in the way of the real work.

Photo: (L to R) RW Jason Chaplin, Bro. Keith Dobbs, and RW Joe Evans at the Metro Region Table Lodge (2026)

The Common Gavel is the operative answer. It removes the rough and superfluous matter so the genuine form underneath can be worked. In the context of relationship, the superfluous matter is the protective veneer that was useful once and has since become load-bearing in the wrong direction. The gavel does not demolish it in one swing. A single swing, applied consistently in low-stakes moments over time, is how the stone actually changes.

Say the Slightly Truer Thing

The central practice is simple enough to sound trivial when stated plainly, and significant enough to be quietly difficult when actually attempted. Say the slightly truer thing. Don’t shout the whole truth or a create a performance of openness. Just the next increment. The answer that is one degree closer to honest than the one you would normally produce.

A Brother asks how you are doing. Your automatic answer is fine. But fine is not accurate. You are tired in a way sleep is not fixing, or something is energizing you in a different way, or you have been thinking about a loss you have not spoken about in years. The slightly truer thing might be as small as: honestly, I have been a little worn down lately and I am not sure why or I’m really excited about some down time this weekend. You do not have to explain it, excavate it, or have it resolved. You let the real surface be present for one moment instead of immediately papering over it.

The capacity for honest contact is trained at the scale where it can actually be sustained. You do not develop it by attempting one heroic act of vulnerability in your most fragile relationship. You develop it by letting the real stone show, slightly, with a Brother you already trust, where the cost of the disclosure is small enough that the practice can actually take hold. Those are not warm-up exercises for the real work. They’re the real work, done at the scale where it sticks.

When you start this practice, the response will not always be what you hoped. Sometimes a Brother meets you, the conversation goes somewhere neither of you planned, and you both walk away slightly less alone. Sometimes what you get is a pause while he recalibrates. Sometimes a deflection back to safer ground. Take each of these as information rather than verdict. The discomfort in the early practice of honest contact, including the discomfort of a less-than-ideal response, is the sign that something is being worked, not evidence that the practice is broken.

There is also an equally important other half: when a Brother eventually offers something real in return, your job is presence, not performance. His disclosure is not an invitation to fix, advise, or judge. It is something to be held. Allowing another man his truth, without routing it into solutions or absorbing it as your own indictment, is the complement to everything you are practicing on your own side of the conversation.

 

What the Lodge Was For

The destination of this work is structural. It is about building relationships, and a fraternity, capable of bearing real weight.

The Masonic lodge is a specific architecture of mutual obligation, men who have made explicit commitments to one another’s wellbeing and to the shared work of becoming better. That architecture fails entirely if the men inside it are performing. A lodge of masks meeting masks is not Brotherhood. It is men standing in proximity to one another, each maintaining a fiction that costs him something every time, and producing in aggregate a room full of Brothers who are still individually alone.

Through the small repeated practice of saying the slightly truer thing, you are actually building something more durable than that. A relationship that does not require performance. A conversation that does not leave you depleted. The experience of being genuinely present with another person rather than simply near them, which most men have glimpsed in their closest friendships and been told is simply luck,

That experience of being known, of having let someone see something real and having watched the relationship survive it and grow stronger for it, is not a rare gift available to fortunate people. It is the patient outcome of operative work, done imperfectly but consistently, in the ordinary moments of an ordinary day.

The Rough Ashlar does not become the Perfect Ashlar in one session or a hundred. There is no finished state. There is only the next moment, with the next Brother, where you have the option of producing the managed answer or one that is slightly closer to true. Across enough of those moments, the lodge becomes what it was always meant to be: a room where men can bring their authentic selves into genuine contact with one another, and in doing so, can finally stop feeling alone inside their own Brotherhood.

Written by Bro. Brian Mattocks, PM

Bro. Brian is a three-time Past Master of Cassia Mt. Horeb Lodge No. 273, F&AM, Grand Lodge of Pennsylvania — and currently serves as Vice Chair of the Pennsylvania Academy of Masonic Knowledge. Brian is also the author and podcast host of A Mason’s Work.

Samuel Lloyd Kinsey

My Journey to the East

My Journey to the East

MASONIC LIFE

My Journey to the East

A Reflection on Brotherhood, Growth, and Service

There are moments in life when we look back and realize that the path we have traveled was shaped not by a single event, but by a series of experiences, friendships, lessons, and opportunities that slowly transformed us into the people we are today. As I begin my term as Junior Warden of my Lodge, St. Patrick’s Lodge No 4 in historic Johnstown, New York, I find myself reflecting on a journey that has spanned decades—a journey of personal growth, Brotherhood, service, and rediscovery.

My Masonic story did not follow a straight path. Like many Brothers, life took me in different directions, and after becoming an Entered Apprentice, I found myself away from the Craft for nearly twenty years. During that time, Freemasonry remained in the background of my life, something unfinished, something I knew I would eventually return to but never quite knew when.

That return began unexpectedly through friendship.
Many years ago, my son William was dating a young woman named Emily. Through our children, I became acquainted with her father, Brother Paul Meher. One evening, Paul invited me to dinner with our families. At the time, I was somewhat uncomfortable. I was still that long-absent Entered Apprentice who had drifted away from Masonry for nearly two decades. Yet from the very beginning, Paul treated me not as someone who had fallen behind, but as a future Brother who simply needed encouragement to continue his journey.

That evening marked the beginning of a friendship that would help reignite my passion for Freemasonry, but the journey that followed became much bigger than any one individual. It became a journey of self-improvement, service, education, and Brotherhood.

Photo: Bro. Russell Dickson (left) being installed as Junior Warden of St. Patrick’s Lodge No 4 on June 4, 2026.

As I returned to the lodge and progressed through the degrees, I discovered that Freemasonry offered far more than ritual and tradition. It provided an opportunity to become a better man. The lessons taught within the lodge room challenged me to examine my character, my responsibilities, and my place within my community. Each degree offered new insights, and each year brought new opportunities to serve. Along the way, I was fortunate to be surrounded by Brothers who freely shared their knowledge and experience. Whether learning ritual, assisting with degree work, helping at lodge events, or simply sitting around the dining hall after meetings, I found myself becoming part of something much larger than myself. The friendships formed within the lodge became some of the most meaningful relationships of my life.

As my involvement grew, so did my commitment. I became active in degree work, where I found great satisfaction in helping candidates experience the same lessons and traditions that had inspired me. Service to the lodge became not an obligation, but a privilege. The journey also led me beyond the Blue Lodge. Together with many Brothers, I became involved in the Scottish Rite, expanding my understanding of Masonic teachings and building friendships with brethren from across the region. Through these experiences, I gained a deeper appreciation for the principles that unite Masons everywhere: Brotherly love, relief, and truth.

Looking back now, I realize that the greatest gift Freemasonry has given me has not been titles, offices, or recognition. It has been growth. It has challenged me to become more patient, more charitable, more understanding, and more willing to serve others. It has connected me with men who inspire me to continually improve myself and who remind me that none of us walks this path alone.

Today, as I proudly serve as Junior Warden and continue my progression through the officer line of St. Patrick’s Lodge No 4, I am filled with gratitude for every Brother who has helped shape my journey. The road to the East is not about personal achievement; it is about preparing oneself to better serve the lodge and the Brethren entrusted to our care.

The friendships, lessons, and experiences gained along the way have already made the journey worthwhile. Whatever lies ahead, I know that the true reward has been the opportunity to walk this path alongside so many remarkable Brothers and to continue striving toward the ideals that Freemasonry teaches us every day.

For me, that journey is still unfolding, and I look forward to wherever it may lead.

Written by Bro. Russell W. Dickson

Bro. Dickson is the Junior Warden in St. Patrick’s Lodge 4 and is at labor in Collabergh-Radium 859, both in New York. He is a Royal Arch Mason in Hiram Union Chapter 53, and is a 32° Scottish Rite Mason at the Valley of Schenectady, where he serves as Thrice Potent Master of the Lodge of Perfection.

Samuel Lloyd Kinsey

Brotherhood Beyond the Lodge Room

Brotherhood Beyond the Lodge Room

MASONIC LIFE

The Bonds Between Us

Brotherhood Beyond the Lodge Room

At the heart of Freemasonry is something far simpler-and far more important-than titles, meetings, or ritual. It is the bond between brothers. Lodges are built on traditions, ceremonies, and shared work, but what keeps men returning year after year is often something less formal. It is the conversations before a meeting begins. The dinners shared around a table. The phone call checking in on a brother who has not been seen in a while. The friendships formed over years of labor, fellowship, and mutual support.

As the Masonic year comes to a close and many lodges prepare to go dark for the summer, we are reminded that Masonry does not exist only within the walls of the lodge room. The bonds formed there continue long after the meeting ends. Brotherhood is carried into everyday life-in moments of support, encouragement, laughter, and simple companionship.

In a world that often feels increasingly disconnected, the fraternity offers something rare: genuine human connection built over time. Men of different backgrounds, professions, ages, and perspectives come together not because they are the same, but because they share a common commitment to respect, fellowship, and mutual improvement. That bond is strengthened not only through ritual and meetings, but through presence. By showing up. By checking in. By welcoming new brothers. By continuing conversations outside the lodge room. Some of the strongest acts of brotherhood are often the quietest and least noticed Summer gives us an opportunity to experience that fellowship in a different way. Cookouts. casual gatherings, family events, or simply taking the time to reconnect with one another outside the structure of formal meetings all help strengthen the ties that hold our lodges together.

The work of Masonry is important-but so are the relationships formed through it. Because long after we forget the details of a meeting or the business discussed on a particular evening, we remember the people. We remember the brothers who encouraged us, supported us, laughed with us, and stood beside us through different seasons of life. These relationships are not secondary to Masonry. They are one of its greatest purposes. And they are the bonds that continue to sustain our lodges, our Temple, and our fraternity year after year.

Written by WB Ian M. McHugh
Past Master, Master’s Lodge No 5, Albany, New York
Article was orginially published in the Albany (New York) Masonic Temple Newsletter
(June 2026 edition)

Samuel Lloyd Kinsey

The Secret Connection

The Secret Connection

The Secret Connection

Heal the Divine Spark Within Every Person

“The wonders of the Lord seem scattered without order and design in the field of immensity. They shine like countless flowers scattered by spring across our meadows. Let’s not seek a more orderly plan to describe them. All beings’ principles are connected to you. It’s their secret connection with you that gives them value, regardless of the place or rank they hold.” – Man of Desire, Louis-Claude de Saint-Martin

I read this quote from Louis Claude de Saint-Martin’s wrote, “Man of Desire“, sparking images of patients I had seen during my many night shifts as a neurology resident. Each with their own story of how they ended up in the hospital and, now, on my clinical radar. Each patient came from different socioeconomic backgrounds – those experiencing homelessness to those at the apex of the social hierarchy. Somehow, all of them were mixed together into one setting, time, and location. Upon reflection, it is rather remarkable what my profession offers and sometimes forces me to confront. Opening one door to the other leads to a completely different story.

Yet, as Saint-Martin so aptly wrote, they all are a part of the story of my own journey of self discovery. The phrase that resonated the most was his idea of a “secret connection”. When bouncing around the hospital, such secret connections often ceased to exist. Patient’s lose a great deal of privacy with lab tests, being woken up, and often disrobed for surgical procedures at the bedside or in the operating theater. Especially in emergencies, such secrets dissolve quickly. However, the intimacy and connection that forms between myself and a patient is deeply moving. In those moments, it is as if some invisible force draws my heart and theirs into a sacred space or union. Perhaps it is our shared humanity in the midst of suffering, death, and the natural laws of entropy we fight against. I’d like to think the secret connection is that of love.

Within the first three degrees of Freemasonry, I found so many lessons and ideas that harken back to my night shifts when all I had to help me was those around me, the patient, myself, and God. Until reading Saint-Martin, I hadn’t realized that the laws of entropy and decay explored in the third degree were describing that unique experience of death that could draw us all into a sacred embrace of God’s love. In those intense moments, patient’s sometimes cry – in fear and joy. Other times, they hug you deeply, hold your hand, or even kiss you on the cheek with deep affection at being with them at the boundary of life and death. Or even walking with them on that path towards that country from whom no traveller returns.

Image: Bro. Jonathan Kopel at Potomac Lodge No 5, Washington, DC with the George Washington Gavel on display

More often, though, patients die. Whether I had realized it at the time, each death can also be a widening barrier between my heart and God’s. I always felt close to my patients. What I hadn’t realized is how death can lead to a growing chasm between myself and God. Despite our own beliefs and expositions from the Third Degree lecture, I believe that we all often avoid discussing how death can still feel like a void that envelops even the divine. A being that somehow overshadows the essence of divine love. A contradiction of how such an envelopment could exist alongside the depth of the human soul and experience. This was especially the case when holding onto loved ones as they cried and wailed in my arms. Sometimes, over the phone. Each experience slowly expanded that chasm between my relationship and God. It was only until I began to process these experiences through writing, therapy, and discussions with brothers and others alike did I slowly begin to see the real beauty of all these moments. Even when death was inevitable or likely, the love and character I showed in those moments was the presence of God shining forth.

The real lesson in residency during those dark nights was this: our light and virtues only shine forth when there is nothing left for us to do to fix a situation except be who we are at our most visceral and vulnerable. When our tools are taken away and our attempts to control the external, what remains is a reflection of what lies in our heart.

These ideas expressed here reminded me of lessons taught in the first and second degrees in a way that made me appreciate and realize the heartwarming messages I hadn’t seen before. Only when confronting death and my relationship with God did I finally understand the beauty and love that lay within me. What was ultimately worth fighting for and striving to perfect. It is why Saint-Martin’s other quote serves as a warning and beautiful reminder of seeing God in both the light and dark. For God’s light is found in all seasons of life. For in the darkness, what is left is the light within. As Saint-Martin wrote:

“It is by penetrating into beings that God makes them feel their life; they are in death as soon as they are no longer in communion with him . All of you, inhabitants of the earth, rejoice, you can contribute to universal communion. You can, like so many vestals, maintain the sacred fire and make it shine in all parts of the universe”

I’ve heard many analogies used to describe the essence of the Craft most of which allude to ideas of balancing the warrior and the scholar – the physical and mental elements of the human person. Yet, I think it’s both simpler and richer. The real essence of the Craft is that of being the healer. A healer to our own being, our fellow human beings, and God. It’s as simple and as complex as this. Through healing ourselves and our fellow neighbors through the lives we live, I think we somehow heal a part of the divine or, at least, contribute to its unfolding story with us. As with my profession, what we heal is our humanity. A reintegration of the divine spark within us to our fellow human beings, creation, and God. A unification of sorts.

Sometimes, it all starts with restoring our own humanity or awareness of it amid the day to day practice of medicine. The art of medicine is having the awareness to bring humanity to each interaction. A healer is one who has the confidence to let go of the medicine and bathe in the life of another person. A lack of fear in being present and allowing whatever to happen to happen without attaching ourselves to a desire to control what cannot be controlled. In the end, none of us can control death. Contrary to what we are taught or expect, many aspects of medicine resolve themselves without our contribution. I often think that being a healer is a lifelong journey of puffing our belly full of knowledge and nudging a patient in the right direction. The river takes them the rest of the way. Much of healing is embracing paradoxes that, for some reason, seem to work themselves out. The principle is to nudge the person and allow the universe and God to work through that mystery.

The secret connection is that invisible fiber that connects us all. Perhaps life, death, illness, recovery, and the inevitable laws of entropy are simply the ingredients of what life upholds to teach us this very important lesson. A lesson that is encapsulated in the very idea of love expressed throughout the degrees. For it is love that draws us into the Craft, love that embraces us during our trek through life, and love that helps us through to the other side where the real mystery and journey of life begins and ends. I only hope my actions and story reflect a heart that is worthy to be carried on in the lives of those yet to be born, who now live, and who have passed on already.

Written by: Bro. Jonathan Kopel

 

Bro. Kopel is a MD PhD in his neurology residency in Washington DC. He is a member of Potomac Lodge #5 and Benjamin B. French Lodge #15 of the Grand Lodge of the District of Columbia, Washington, DC.

Samuel Lloyd Kinsey
Being an Upright Man in an Upside-Down World

Being an Upright Man in an Upside-Down World

MASONIC LIFE

Being an Upright Man in an Upside-Down World

In a world that often feels upside-down, where division is currency and outrage is a daily expectation, the idea of being an upright man may seem almost old-fashioned. But within Freemasonry, uprightness is not just a moral suggestion; it is a cornerstone. The Craft teaches that a man’s character is measured not by the noise of his opinions, but by the steadiness of his actions. In the swirling currents of modern political and religious extremism, these lessons are more important than ever.

Freemasonry asks every initiate one question that echoes through every Lodge: What kind of man will you choose to be? Not what party you support, what faith you follow, or what ideology you prefer, but what virtues you will embody when confronted with conflict, fear, and uncertainty.

In an age where social media amplifies hostility and public discourse rewards the loudest voice rather than the wisest, Masonry offers an ancient but deeply relevant antidote: the pursuit of balance, tolerance, and Brotherly Love. The idea of being “upright” is symbolized in the Mason’s Plumb Line, a reminder to stand straight, morally and spiritually, no matter how skewed the world around us becomes.

This uprightness is not passive. It is an active, daily discipline. It means questioning our own biases before judging others. It means resisting the seductive pull of extreme rhetoric, even when it flatters our emotions or validates our frustrations. It means responding to hatred not with silence, but with dignity.

Freemasonry provides Brotherhood precisely for this purpose. The Lodge becomes a refuge where men of vastly different backgrounds meet on the Level, without fear of ridicule or retaliation for their beliefs. In a world aggressively sorted into “us” and “them,” a Lodge demonstrates that harmony is not only possible—it is essential. Brotherhood does not erase differences; instead, it elevates the virtues that transcend them: integrity, charity, justice, temperance.

Masonic principles challenge the notion that disagreement must be destructive. A true Mason learns to listen, to seek common ground, and to engage without malice. He does not confuse firmness of belief with intolerance, nor does he surrender his convictions simply to avoid discomfort. Instead, he moves through the world with measured thought, guided by the Square and Compasses — the Working Tools that remind him to Square his actions with virtue and circumscribe his passions before they overtake him.

In a free society, where political and religious extremes can blur the line between conviction and fanaticism, this discipline becomes a form of resistance. A Mason resists the temptation to dehumanize opponents. He resists the urge to treat complex issues as simple binaries. He resists the pressure to meet anger with more anger. Uprightness becomes not just a moral stance but a stabilizing force.

The Craft also teaches that no man must stand alone. Brotherhood strengthens resolve. When the world becomes loud, divided, or hostile, a Mason can look to his Brothers for counsel, for perspective, and for the reminder that the Light is always present, even when obscured by the noise of the moment. This shared commitment allows Masons to walk through the world not as combatants in a cultural war, but as steady examples of civility and strength. Ultimately, an upright man in an upside-down world does not seek to dominate others, but to inspire them. He becomes a quiet but powerful statement of what humanity can look like when guided by principle rather than passion. In this way, Freemasonry remains not a relic of a bygone era but a timeless guide, helping men navigate the chaos with wisdom, courage, and Brotherly Love.

Written by Bro. Russell W. Dickson

Bro. Dickson is the Senior Deacon in St. Patrick’s Lodge 4 and is at labor in Collabergh-Radium 859, both in New York. He is a Royal Arch Mason in Hiram Union Chapter 53, and is a 32° Scottish Rite Mason at the Valley of Schenectady, where he serves as Senior Warden of Sigma Council Princes of Jerusalem.

Samuel Lloyd Kinsey