MASONIC RITUAL
The Three Levels of Masonic Meaning
MASONIC RITUAL EXPLAINED BY THE CHAIRMAN OF THE CUSTODIANS OF THE WORK
Our Rituals, symbols and allegories are among our great treasures, but our method is not without its challenges for the Mason seeking enlightenment and knowledge. In fact, a central challenge arises from the very strength of the symbolic method: A symbol may represent one thing, but it may also represent many things. And it has even been said that the most powerful symbols are those to which many different meanings can be ascribed. That's certainly true of Freemasonry, as our symbols have given rise to a vast profusion of written work exploring and interpreting their meanings from a broad and diverse range of traditions and viewpoints. The question therefore naturally arises as to which one is right and true, and the answer is as unsatisfying as it is brief: It depends.
The good news is that there is an almost infinite number of "right answers" that can be built upon a solid basis of knowledge. Acquiring this knowledge, however, sometimes can be difficult. For the most part, the most common books available set forth the authors’ personal interpretations of Masonic Ritual and symbols rather than providing detailed factual information such as a symbol’s origins, how it came to be used in Masonry and how its usage has evolved over time—the kind of information that a Mason might use as a foundation upon which to build his own interpretations, and to contextualize the interpretations of others. This brings us to what I have called the Three Levels of Masonic Meaning.
The first level of Masonic meaning is the Ritual Level. Our Ritual teaches certain lessons and ascribes certain meanings to the elements and symbols contained within it. Effectively, this level of meaning doesn’t require much explanation because the explanation is already set forth in the Ritual. It is what it says it is. The actual words of our Ritual comprise the bedrock level of meaning which supports our Masonic edifice.
Photo: RWB Jason W. Short studying his degree part.
The second level of Masonic meaning is the Information Level. This is comprised of all the factual details that might inform our understanding of a symbol or an element of Masonic Ritual including its source, its history, meaning and context outside of the Masonic tradition, its Masonic history, and its evolution within the Craft as well as the lessons, meanings and connections that flow directly from this information. This sort of knowledge represents the foundation level of meaning, providing a firm basis upon which each individual Mason may later erect his own personal understanding of Masonry.
The third level of Masonic meaning is the Speculative Level. This encompasses all the interpretations that can be construed and constructed out of the Rituals, symbols and lessons of Freemasonry. Here is where we properly place the works of Albert Pike, Manley Hall, Daniel Béresniak, Kirk MacNulty, Carl H. Claudy and others, as well as the multiplicity of books, papers, speeches, short talks and even extended Degree rites applying various belief systems, traditions, ideas and interpretations to Masonic Ritual and symbolism. We should be reminded, however, that none of the thoughts supplied or answers proposed within them can be regarded definitive insofar as Masonry is concerned. Speculation is one of Masonry’s greatest traditions, but it is inherently personal and individual.
Photo: A copy of Anderson's Book of Constitutions, under display glass.
Another way of looking at these three levels of Masonic meaning would be to say that the Ritual Level has only one right answer for a given Ritual tradition, the Information Level has many right answers albeit in a finite amount, and the Speculative Level has an infinite number of right answers. But in every case each level is, or ought to be, built upon right answers from the levels below.
Response provided by RW Samuel Lloyd Kinsey
Chairman, Custodians of the Work, Grand Lodge of New York
Note: This site is an excellent source of information about Freemasonry. While every effort has been made to provide accurate and up-to-date information about Masonic Ritual, please remember that a website is not a substitute for your jurisdiction's Standard Work or Approved Ritual.