More Than Just Members: Reflecting on the Heart of Freemasonry

More Than Just Members: Reflecting on the Heart of Freemasonry

MASONIC EDITORIAL

More Than Just Members: Reflecting on the Heart of Freemasonry

 

My Brethren all, today I share with you a piece that reflects my own opinions. Those of you who know me within the Craft by name or reputation know that I truly love “this thing of ours.” I love what I believe it is meant to do, its purpose, and what it stands for. I’ve wanted to write something like this for a while, and until recently, I wasn’t sure how to convey it. But my Brothers, I have found the words. I want to evoke a sense of nostalgia in the older reader, pride in the younger reader, and encourage everyone to think – to think about themselves, the brother on their right and left, the brother who doesn’t attend lodge as often as we’d like, and the prospective member who has yet to enter our doors. My Brothers, I hope this article makes you think and ignites a fire within you and your lodge – a fire that may need reigniting or perhaps one that will burn even more passionately and stronger.

I’m sure some of you, having read the title, are wondering, “What is this?” or “Why would he write this?” Why? Because, as I said before, I love this Craft, I love my fellow Masons, and I want to be known as a Mason who inspires others, who makes people think, but more importantly, who makes good men better. Now, let’s get into it!

Don’t be a Mason if your search within this fraternity is based on seeking personal merits. If you intend to stand out above others, if you crave or mistakenly believe that you will find recognition, fame, or wealth within “this thing of ours”, then you are on the wrong path.

Masonry is not a stage for selfishness nor a means to achieve individual glory. Rather, it is a sacred space where humanity, tolerance, and selfless service are the pillars that support our work

Don’t be a Mason if your purpose is to take advantage of this fraternity for your own interests. Masonry teaches us to be men of principle, committed to the well-being of our community and the development of our virtues. If your gaze is focused on what you can get instead of what you can offer, then you are not ready to embrace the true Masonic spirit.

Masonry invites us to use the mallet with enough force to carve the rough stone, enabling us to build the immense edifice that is humanity, but never with excessive force that disregards intelligence, which would only destroy what we have achieved. In its teachings, the fraternity always emphasizes unity, not division.

Being a Mason means working on the continuous improvement of oneself and others; it is to be a beacon of light in the darkness and an example of integrity and honor for all. Each one of us is responsible for cultivating these qualities and virtues. Only then will we be able to honor the values transmitted to us through the centuries by our ancestors.

My Brothers, I urge you to ask yourselves: What are your true intentions in crossing through this door? Is it your desire to grow in wisdom? To build bonds of brotherhood? To contribute to the well-being of humanity? If you answered yes to any of those questions, then you have a place in our fraternity, and for all of you who answered yes, WELCOME!

To quote someone I admire and who has personally motivated me within the lodge and beyond, R.W. John McKoy: “Being a good man is not something you take with you, but it is something you leave behind. It is something you pass on.” I don’t know if John knows how profound I found that statement and how often I think about it. I’m even willing to bet John doesn’t remember saying it, but it’s something I have thought about regularly since 2019 and has been a daily driving force in my life.

Freemasonry is a journey of self-knowledge, dedication, and love for one another. Our actions must speak louder than our words, so that in the end, we can look back with pride, knowing that we have been true Masons in every step we have taken throughout our lives. Then, when our end comes, we can leave this world with pride and the satisfaction of duty fulfilled.

Thank you for the opportunity to share my thoughts and opinions with you. I hope you reflect on your Masonic journeys and remember what drove you to become a Mason. I hope that any lost passion has been reignited, and if your passion remains, I hope this reflection only intensifies it. I truly believe that as men and Masons, we serve a greater purpose. We should forever strive not just to make good men better, but also to continue working on becoming the best versions of ourselves.

Thank you again, my Brothers, for reading. May the Great Architect bless each and every one of you and your loved ones. I wish you health and happiness.

Written by: WB Lee Eitelberg WB Eitelberg is the current sitting Master of Cornucopia Lodge No. 563 (2025). He is also a 32° Freemason (Scottish Rite Northern Masonic Jurisdiction) and a proud Shriner.
Samuel Lloyd Kinsey
Examining Masonic Membership

Examining Masonic Membership

CRAFTSMEN ONLINE PODCAST

“Examining Masonic Membership”

with Bro. Matthew Brockbank

In a thought-provoking episode of the Craftsman Online Podcast, Matthew Brockbank, a returning guest and keen observer of Freemasonry, tackles the complex issue of Masonic membership and retention. Drawing on his experience and sociological background, Brockbank conducted a survey focusing on why members leave Freemasonry, offering valuable insights that challenge conventional thinking and provide a roadmap for potential change.

Brockbank’s approach is both methodical and deeply reflective. “I wanted to find out where we’re going wrong,” he states, emphasizing the importance of diagnosing the problem before attempting to fix it. Eschewing assumptions, he sought concrete feedback from those who had demitted, resigned, or withdrawn their membership, aiming to understand the reasons behind their departure.

The responses varied, revealing that the reasons for leaving were not always as simple as relocation or life changes. Brockbank notes, “To tell you the truth, I got a range of responses, and to be honest, some of which did involve some form of conflict, whether it be physical, mental, or emotional.” This acknowledgment of internal issues within lodges challenges the often-idealized image of Masonic brotherhood and calls for a willingness to confront uncomfortable truths.  

However, it wasn’t all negative. Brockbank highlights a significant finding: “Everyone had something good to say.” This underscores the complexity of the issue; even those who chose to leave often held positive views of individual members and the overall Masonic experience.  

Ultimately, Brockbank’s research points to a need for self-reflection and change within Freemasonry. “I feel like Freemasonry has an opportunity to be something amazing in the next 50 to 100 years,” he asserts, emphasizing the potential for growth and renewal. His insights offer a compelling call to action: to address the issues that drive members away and to create a more relevant and sustainable future for the Craft.

Follow the Craftsmen Online Podcast on Spotify, subscribe on Apple Podcasts, and listen everywhere you hear your favorite shows!

The Craftsmen Online Podcast is the only Masonic podcast endorsed by the Grand Lodge of New York. Hosted by RWB Michael Arce. New episodes available every Monday morning!

Listen early and ad free on Patreon. Start your free 7-day trial and listen to our entire back catalog and bonus content!

Samuel Lloyd Kinsey

The Hero’s Journey and Freemasonry

The Hero’s Journey and Freemasonry

CRAFTSMEN ONLINE PODCAST

“The Hero’s Journey and Freemasonry”

with WB Bull Garlington

In a recent episode of the Craftsman Online Podcast, Worshipful Brother Bull Garlington shared his unique insights into the connection between the hero’s journey and Freemasonry. Garlington, a storyteller and mythologist, draws upon his extensive knowledge of Joseph Campbell’s monomyth to illustrate how it dovetails with the Masonic journey.   For those unfamiliar with Joseph Campbell, Garlington explains, “Basically what Joseph Campbell did, Joseph, he was a mythologist…he studied myth and he would travel the world and he would dig through libraries and he would find the myths of various cultures and strip them down to their bare bones, you know, their bullet points, if you will.” Campbell discovered that despite their cultural differences, these myths followed a similar pattern, a cycle of 12 to 17 steps that a hero must undergo for the story to be complete.
Garlington argues that this heroic cycle is mirrored in the Masonic journey. Just as the hero of a myth embarks on a transformative quest, so does the Freemason. “When you cross over the literal threshold in Freemasonry and step into an actual lodge for the first time,” Garlington says, “that is going from the world of the known to the unknown.” This crossing of the threshold is a decisive moment, marking the initiate’s entry into a new world of meaning and purpose.   The parallels between the hero’s journey and Freemasonry don’t end there. Garlington points out the importance of mentorship in both contexts. Just as the hero often has a mentor to guide them, Freemasons also benefit from the wisdom and support of their brothers. Garlington notes, “Mentorship is not necessarily about age. Mentorship is not even about where you are in your degrees. Mentorship is about understanding and loving this other dude and just basically supporting him in ways that aren’t written down anywhere.”   Ultimately, Garlington believes that the search for meaning is at the heart of both the hero’s journey and the Masonic experience. “What these guys are looking for when they come to Freemasonry,” he states, “is meaning. They want to give their life meaning.” It is this quest for self-actualization that drives men to seek out Freemasonry, and it is the transformative power of the Masonic journey that helps them find it.

Follow the Craftsmen Online Podcast on Spotify, subscribe on Apple Podcasts, and listen everywhere you hear your favorite shows!

The Craftsmen Online Podcast is the only Masonic podcast endorsed by the Grand Lodge of New York. Hosted by RWB Michael Arce. New episodes available every Monday morning! Listen early and ad free on Patreon. Start your free 7-day trial and listen to our entire back catalog and bonus content!
Samuel Lloyd Kinsey
Preston vs Webb The Battle for Masonic Ritual Supremacy

Preston vs Webb The Battle for Masonic Ritual Supremacy

CRAFTSMEN ONLINE PODCAST

“Preston vs. Webb:
The Battle for Masonic Ritual Supremacy”

with WB Nathan St. Pierre

In the latest episode of the Craftsmen Online Podcast, Worshipful Brother Nathan St. Pierre returns to the show to discuss the legendary figures of William Preston and Thomas Smith Webb and their massive influence on Freemasonic ritual.

 

Who Were Preston and Webb?

Preston, born in Scotland in 1742, was a bookbinder and printer who became a Mason in 1763. He was a champion of Masonic education and is known for the historical lectures of the three degrees.

Webb, born in Boston in 1771, was a well-educated, extroverted musician and printer. He is credited with creating the York Rite and what is known outside of the United States as the American Rite.

Preston’s Focus: Knowledge

Preston believed that Freemasonry was about the perpetual pursuit of knowledge and preserving it. He was constantly writing and rewriting his lectures, incorporating historical references and etymology.

Webb’s Goal: National Ritual Unity

Webb, on the other hand, focused on establishing a standardized system of Masonic ritual in the United States. He published “The Freemason’s Monitor” in 1797, which became the basis of all American ritual.

The Blending of Two Philosophies

The philosophies of Preston and Webb were very different. Preston’s lectures were aimed at educating and inspiring Masons, while Webb sought to codify the ritual. Their works were combined and have had a lasting impact on the Craft.

 

Key Points From the Episode

  • Preston and Webb did not know each other.
  • Webb took Preston’s work, removed references to the monarchy, and simplified it.
  • There is no one Prestonian work, as he was constantly revising his lectures.
  • Webb was an entrepreneur who sold his monitor and ciphered portions of the ritual.
  • American lodges ended up doing ancients work because of Webb’s publications, regardless of their Grand Lodge affiliation.
  • Differences in ritual between jurisdictions are often more recent than people think.
  • Grand Lodges often claim their ritual is the most accurate.
  • The plain text portions of ritual are called monitorial because they come from Webb’s monitor.
  • The goal of memorizing the ritual is that the words become a part of the Mason.

Listen to the Episode

Follow the Craftsmen Online Podcast on Spotify, subscribe on Apple Podcasts, and listen everywhere you hear your favorite shows!

The Craftsmen Online Podcast is the only Masonic podcast endorsed by the Grand Lodge of New York. Hosted by RWB Michael Arce. New episodes available every Monday morning!

Listen early and ad free on Patreon. Start your free 7-day trial and listen to our entire back catalog and bonus content!

Samuel Lloyd Kinsey

Oklahoma City National Memorial Museum

Oklahoma City National Memorial Museum

BROTHERHOOD

Oklahoma City National Memorial Museum

Honoring those who were killed, those who survived and those changed forever.

Hello again Craftsmen Online followers, Brothers, and friends!

Did you know that the Oklahoma City National Memorial Museum is in a historic Masonic building? I did not! As the unofficial traveling man of Craftsmen Online, I stumbled on yet another Masonic site. I travel for work, for Shriner fundraisers, and for fun all over the world and somehow, I almost always bump into a Brother or Masonic site. This was yet another case of trying to learn more about the history of Oklahoma City and finding myself in an amazing masonic building.

I was in town for a Shriner fundraiser and had a free day to explore the city. The security guard at the museum entrance asked me where I was from and when I told him I was a Shriner in town for a fundraiser, he said I needed to go to the front of the building and read the cornerstone plaque. It clearly stated that the building (Masonic Temple & Shrine Auditorium) was erected in 1922 by the Masonic Temple building Association of Oklahoma City. The cornerstone was laid by the AF&AM Most Worshipful Grand Master Leslie H Swan.

Inside, the building has been completely transformed into a very moving exhibit. There is a memorial of the Oklahoma City Bombing, which took place on the morning of April 19, 1995. At 9:02 am, the bomb Timothy McVeigh built inside of a rented Ryder truck exploded in front of the Alfred P. Murrah Federal Building in downtown Oklahoma City. Dozens of cars were incinerated and more than 300 nearby buildings were damaged or destroyed. The human toll was still more devastating: 168 souls lost, including 19 children, with several hundred more injured.

2025 marks the 30th anniversary of “the day of darkness” which the museum is honoring with the year of Light.

And at times it is hard not to be overwhelmed by the raw emotions of that terrible day. When you explore the museum, it is, in my opinion, virtually impossible to not get choked up from memories of that day in history. The Masonic building only suffered minor damage to the back of the building from the explosion and due to its proximity to the Federal building made it the perfect building to honor those that lost their lives on that faithful day.

Most of my Masonic interactions and Masonic discoveries are light, educational, and up lifting. This one hit much differently, however, I feel that the Brothers that were responsible for constructing this building are happy to know the Masonic Temple & Shrine Auditorium is going to be a part of American history forever. I recommend you make sure this is on your list of must-see museums in the US. We all need to never forget this tragic event so we can help make sure something like this does not happen again.

Travel well and often.

RW Anthony Prizzia
Past Master of Adonai Lodge #718, Highland, New York
Bro. Prizzia is also a proud member of:
Cyprus Shrine, Oriental Shrine, and Ulster County Shrine Club
Valley of Albany A.A.S.R
Poughkeepsie Chapter 172
Poughkeepsie Commandery 43
Royal Order of Scotland