What the Founders Meant by Happiness
CRAFTSMEN ONLINE PODCAST
What the Founders Meant by Happiness
A discussion on virtue and character
What did the American founders mean by the pursuit of happiness? On a recent panel for the Craftsman Online Podcast, RW Michael Arce led an in-depth discussion on this vital topic. The panel featured legal scholar Jeffrey Rosen, Dr. Ted Cross from Arizona State University, and historians RW Lee Justo and Bro. Chris Ruli. Together, they explored the classical roots of character, the dangers of modern digital technology, and the daily duties of every citizen in a free society.
Modern culture often defines happiness as comfort, entertainment, wealth, or instant gratification. The founders held a completely different view. Jeffrey Rosen explained that for figures like Thomas Jefferson and Benjamin Franklin, happiness did not mean feeling good. It meant being good. They drew this definition from classical moral philosophy, especially Cicero and his Tusculan Disputations. Happiness required self-mastery, moral discipline, and reason. A person had to use reason to manage irrational passions and emotions in order to achieve tranquility and serve the public good.
This philosophical foundation traces back to Pythagoras. Pythagoras divided the human soul into three parts: reason in the head, passion in the heart, and desire in the stomach. He taught that reason must direct our desires. Pythagoras also introduced the practice of daily self-accounting. Benjamin Franklin later adapted this method into his famous chart of thirteen virtues, reviewing his personal conduct every night to identify where he fell short and resolve to do better.
Dr. Ted Cross reinforced this principle through his leadership in character education at Arizona State University. He noted that modern life is filled with artificial online happiness and performative consumption. Higher education often focuses only on helping people make a living. Cross argued that institutions must also teach people how to live a good life. Real flourishing comes from identifying core values across moral, civic, intellectual, and performance domains, then putting those values into daily practice.
The panel examined why this classical view of character is essential for the survival of the republic. James Madison believed that personal self-government is necessary for political self-government. A free nation cannot endure if citizens divide into factions driven by selfish passions rather than reason. Madison designed constitutional systems with speed bumps and cooling mechanisms, hoping that deliberate debate would allow reason to spread across the country.
Modern technology has disrupted those original safeguards. Instant communication removes the time needed for calm deliberation. Social media algorithms create echo chambers, deepen political division, and promote shallow online outrage. Rosen pointed out that constant screen use has broken our habit of deep reading. When people stop reading primary sources, they lose the ability to think independently and instead surrender their judgment to partisan factions.
Historians Bro. Chris Ruli and RW Lee Justo explained how civic organizations historically countered this isolation. In early America, fraternal groups and local associations brought together people of different backgrounds to focus on shared moral values and civic improvement. Members established early public libraries, supported public education, and led local charities. Character was understood not as a static trait, but as a continuous discipline practiced within a community.
To help Americans reclaim these principles, Arizona State University and the National Constitution Center launched a free online course titled The Pursuit of Happiness. The twelve-module program studies the character and struggles of American leaders from Washington to Abraham Lincoln and Frederick Douglass.
Our panel concluded with practical actions that anyone can take immediately to build personal character and strengthen civic life:
- Create time for daily reflection. Ted Cross advised people to identify their personal values and examine how they live up to them each day.
- Honor the sacrifices of past generations. Lee Justo cited John Adams, who warned that freedom requires great pain to preserve and demands that future generations make good use of it.
- Study original primary sources directly. Chris Ruli urged citizens to read the Constitution, the Declaration of Independence, and historical letters rather than relying on modern summaries and commentary.
- Commit to a daily practice of deep reading. Jeffrey Rosen recommended spending at least fifteen to thirty minutes every morning reading books or primary texts before looking at email or social media.
- Remain active, curious, and informed. Michael Arce emphasized that citizens must ask questions, engage locally, and show up for their communities.
By recovering the classical pursuit of happiness, citizens can master their passions, think for themselves, and protect the foundations of American freedom.
Listen to the Craftsmen Online Podcast everywhere you hear your favorite shows and watch us on YouTube. New episodes every Monday morning.